But the following, which do bring up the cud or have true hoofs which are cleft through, you may not eat: the camel, the hare, and the hyrax — for although they bring up the cud, they have no true hoofs — they are unclean for you; also the swine — for although it has true hoofs, it does not bring up the cud — is unclean for you. You shall not eat of their flesh or touch their carcasses. – Deuteronomy 14:7-8
Have you ever wondered why the pig has become such a primary symbol for Jewish dietary laws? People who know little else about Jews will tell you that Jews don’t eat pork. Jews who are not concerned about cheeseburgers or shrimp sushi will still feel a twinge (or frisson?) of transgression when they eat a slice of bacon.
How did the pig, which is listed almost as an afterthought in this passage from Deuteronomy, become so important a symbol of all that is not-Jewish?
Richard Redding, an archaeologist at the University of Michigan, has made a serious study of the role of the pig in the ancient Near Eastern diet. Wild pigs were indigenous to the ancient Near East, and we know from archaeological remains that they were domesticated and eaten in Egypt in the Old Kingdom period, (2700-2055 BCE.) His research suggests that pigs gradually declined in use wherever water was scarce, because chickens provided more efficient sources of protein. This has led some Jewish thinkers to ask, is THIS the real reason that pig was prohibited in the Torah? We’ll never get the definitive answer to that, but it adds another theory for those who are interested in such theories.
(In case you are wondering: there’s no evidence in the Bible text itself that pork is forbidden for being unhealthy, because of trichinosis, or because refrigeration hadn’t been invented. The only reason for the dietary prohibitions in the Bible is that old standby of deities and parents over the centuries: “Because I said so.”)
However, the question stands: why did pork take on so much more significance than any other of the forbidden foods?
Redding mentions in his article that the consumption of pig meat began to increase in the region starting in the 2nd century BCE, with the growth in Hellenistic populations. Greeks brought pigs with them and cultivated them. Romans loved their pork. So just as rabbinic Judaism was beginning to take shape, the foreigners most despised by the Jews, the upstart rulers who profaned the Temple and imposed ruinous taxes also made that particular forbidden meat fashionable! So there’s one thing: Pork was the meat of choice of Rome and Greece. No wonder the ancient rabbis regarded it as particularly nasty.
Secondly, as Christianity separated from Judaism sometime around the end of the first century CE, it embraced the Gentile world and its diet. Among the attractions Christianity had to offer was the fact that one did not need to be circumcised or eschew pork to be one of the elect. Later, when it became the established religion of the Empire and later of Europe, the fact that Jews avoided eating pork became a “tell,” a hallmark of Jewishness.
During the Middle Ages, pork became not only a way to identify a Jew, but a way to humiliate and torture Jews. Jews were starved, then offered pork to eat. In Spain, those suspected of being hidden Jews were called Marranos (“pigs.”) In the 20th century, we know that in at least one camp the Nazis fed Jews dried pigs’ feet (Elie Weisel, Night.) Centuries of this association forged a strong connection between the non-consumption of pork and Jewish identity.
Many American and Israeli Jews today choose not to keep kosher, and they consume pork as well. However, even the most secular will attach a certain angst to pork consumption that they don’t attach to shrimp cocktail. Pig meat, an afterthought in Deuteronomy, became a potent symbol for Jewish identity. The reason? History.
5 thoughts on “What Makes the Pig So Special?”
Thank you for this, Rabbi, I’ve often wondered the same thing–why is pork seen as so taboo, more so than shellfish. I believe the Torah text around shellfish has a lot more oomph and is much more no-no-no. I like how you connect the cultural and historical narratives that helped reinforce pork as something that outsiders eat.
One of my other ponder questions is, why such a degree of zealousness (some people kind of go crazy about it) with keeping meat and dairy separate–to the tune of having separate fridges, pots, pans and more, even though the Torah only says not to boil a kid in its mothers milk. Maybe it’s another case of keeping separate from the Gentiles, but I don’t think that explains the zaniness. Thanks again for all your wonderful blog posts!
Hey Anne, here’s an interesting article on the subject of milk and meat in Jewish practice and thought: http://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/1149824/jewish/Meat-Milk.htm
I love that Jewish ritual has deeper spiritual meaning that can add an enriching layer of depth to our everyday lives. Enjoy!
(I posted in a separate reply to Rabbi Adar’s thought-provoking article a link to an article on the spiritual significance of the eschewing — not chewing! — of pork in Jewish tradition. Check it out.)
Also, when you are herders… well, pigs don’t herd real well like sheep and goats do.
Here’s a great article on this subject: http://www.aish.com/tp/i/moha/When-Pigs-Fly.html
It offers stimulating insights from our tradition as to why pigs in particular are the most loathed among the non-kosher animals. Definitely more meaningful than a simple, “Because I said so.” The mitzvot remain so beautiful, meaning and relevant even today!