“Why is it taking so long? I can’t wait to get to the mikveh!”
If I had a nickel for every time a student has said that to me, we could go get fancy espresso drinks. There is something about being “in a process” or “on a journey” that makes us long for the destination and impatient to “arrive.”
Here’s the deal: Conversion to Judaism is a very serious matter. It’s serious for the person making this change, and it is also serious for the Jewish People. In the Middle Ages, it was illegal for Jews to convert Christians or Muslims to Judaism, and the repercussions could be terrible for the entire Jewish community. Today, it isn’t quite as dramatic, but what it boils down to is, once you are a member of the tribe, you are a part of us. We’re stuck with you, and you’re stuck with us. The saying is, Kol Yisrael aravim zeh l’zeh [“All Israel is responsible one for another.”] So the time of study, the courtship, is long and slow.
It takes a year to experience each of the Jewish holidays, and to experience the feeling of being apart from celebrations that we leave behind. Your relationship to the old holidays will change. Your relationships to family members and friends will shift to include the changes in your life. You will also make new friends, explore new possibilities in the Jewish community. None of this can happen quickly.
This is a very precious time. Congregational rabbis make an extraordinary investment of time and effort in candidates for conversion, because there is not only much to learn, but much emotional ground to cover. Most students meet regularly with their rabbi as they move through the year or more of study. The rabbi will not schedule a beit din or the mikveh until he or she is sure that this person is ready to move forward as an adult member of the Jewish community – that is, without the special support that a candidate receives.
So don’t get in a rush. Don’t worry about “when.” Studying for conversion is a special time, a time that, once over, will never come again. A new Jew is an adult member of the community, and they’re on their own: to work on committees, to choose classes or study, to be as involved as they want. But the days of being a baby bird will be over.
Conversion to Judaism is a long process: for most, it takes at least a year, and for some, more than that. The point is not to do it quickly, but to do it well. I wish you a challenging and rewarding process!
2 thoughts on “Why Does Conversion to Judaism Take So Long?”
“Studying for conversion is a special time, a time that, once over, will never come again.” Just reading that gave me a shiver. How often do we rush thorough life only to look back and say, “Oh, is it over so soon?”
A woman who was speaking about her conversion on a panel some years ago told the audience, “I put off my trip to the mikvah as long as I could. Because I knew that once I went, the regular meetings with my rabbi would end and I didn’t want to let them go.”
Once it is over and done I hope Jews by choice will find a way to see their beloved rabbi frequently, whether it is going to services or serving on a committee, or going to Torah study. But it will be as a grown up Jew. In time, being a grown up is pretty darn nice too.